Hípias menor
- Idioma:
- anglès
- Traducció:
- Benjamin Jowett
- Completesa:
- Obra completa
- Autoria:
- Escrita per l'autor
- Estat del text:
- Text net
- Extensió:
- ~6.320 paraules · 30 passatges
Cita aquesta obra
- APAPlató. (n.d.). Hípias menor. SigPhi. https://sigphiai.com/ca/works/plato/lesser-hippias
- MLAPlató. "Hípias menor." SigPhi, https://sigphiai.com/ca/works/plato/lesser-hippias.
- ChicagoPlató. Hípias menor. SigPhi. https://sigphiai.com/ca/works/plato/lesser-hippias.
De què tracta
Qui menteix a posta és millor que qui s'equivoca sense voler? Sòcrates hi arriba per un argument que ell mateix diu que no s'acaba de creure.
Context i història
Un diàleg curt i incòmode: la conclusió és òbviament falsa i Plató la deixa dreta a posta. Serveix per veure què passa quan l'intel·lectualisme moral socràtic —ningú no fa el mal sabent-ho— es porta fins al final. Alguns editors antics en van dubtar l'autenticitat justament per això.
Context editorial, no una font citable: a diferència dels passatges de l'obra, aquestes dades no es poden contrastar amb el corpus.
EUDICUS: Why are you silent, Socrates, after the magnificent display which Hippias has been making? Why do you not either refute his words, if he seems to you to have been wrong in any point, or join with us in commending him? There is the more reason why you should speak, because we are now alone, and the audience is confined to those who may fairly claim to take part in a philosophical discussion. SOCRATES: I should greatly like, Eudicus, to ask Hippias the meaning of what he was saying just now about Homer. I have heard your father, Apemantus, declare that the Iliad of Homer is a finer poem than the Odyssey in the same degree that Achilles was a better man than Odysseus; Odysseus, he would say, is the central figure of the one poem and Achilles of the other. Now, I should like to know, if Hippias has no objection to tell me, what he thinks about these two heroes, and which of them he maintains to be the better; he has already told us in the course of his exhibition many things of various kinds about Homer and divers other poets. EUDICUS: I am sure that Hippias will be delighted to answer anything which you would like to ask; tell me, Hippias, if Socrates asks you a question, will you answer him? HIPPIAS: Indeed, Eudicus, I should be strangely inconsistent if I refused to answer Socrates, when at each Olympic festival, as I went up from my house at Elis to the temple of Olympia, where all the Hellenes were assembled, I continually professed my willingness to perform any of the exhibitions which I had prepared, and to answer any questions which any one had to ask. SOCRATES: Truly, Hippias, you are to be congratulated, if at every Olympic festival you have such an encouraging opinion of your own wisdom when you go up to the temple. I doubt whether any muscular hero would be so fearless and confident in offering his body to the combat at Olympia, as you are in offering your mind.…
De què tracta Hípias menor?Resumeix Hípias menor en poques paraulesQuines són les idees clau de Hípias menor?
← Torna a Plató