In what sense a sinless righteousness in this life can be asserted 112 Although perfect righteousness be not found hereon earth, it is still not impossible, 113 44 45 46.
IN ONE BOOK, ADDRESSED TO MARCELLINUS, A.D. 412.
MARCELLINUS, IN A LETTER TO AUGUSTIN, HAD EXPRESSED SOME SURPRISE AT HAVING READ, IN THE PRECEDING WORK, OF THE POSSIBILITY BEING ALLOWED OF A MAN CONTINUING IF HE WILLED IT, BY GOD's HELP, WITHOUT SIN IN THE PRESENT LIFE, ALTHOUGH NOT A SINGLE HUMAN EXAMPLE ANYWHERE OF SUCH PERFECT RIGHTEOUSNESS HAS EVER EXISTED. AUGUSTIN TAKES THE OPPOR- TUNITY OF DISCUSSING, IN OPPOSITION TO THE PELAGIANS, THE SUBJECT OF THE AID OF god's GRACE; AND HE SHOWS THAT THE DIVINE HELP TO THE WORKING OF RIGHTEOUSNESS BY US DOES NOT LIE IN THE FACT OF GOD's HAVING GIVEN US A LAW WHICH IS FULL OF GOOD AND HOLY PRECEPTS; BUT IN THE FACT THAT OUR WILL ITSELF, WITHOUT WHICH WE CAN DO NOTHING GOOD, IS ASSISTED AND ELEVATED BY THE SPIRIT OF GRACE BEING IMPARTED TO US, WITHOUT THE AID OF WHICH THE TEACHING OF THE LAW IS "THE LETTER THAT KILLETH," BECAUSE INSTEAD OF JUSTIFYING THE UNGODLY, IT RATHER HOLDS THEM GUILTY OF TRANSGRESSION. HE BEGINS TO TREAT OF THE QUESTION PROPOSED TO HIM AT THE COMMENCEMENT OF THIS WORK, AND RETURNS TO IT TOWARDS ITS CON- CLUSION; HE SHOWS THAT, AS ALL ALLOW, MANY THINGS ARE POSSIBLE WITH god's HELP, OF WHICH THERE OCCURS INDEED NO EXAMPLE; AND THEN CON- CLUDES THAT, ALTHOUGH A PERFECT RIGHTEOUSNESS IS UNEXAMPLED AMONG MEN, IT IS FOR ALL THAT NOT IMPOSSIBLE.
CHAP. I [l.] — THE OCCASION OF WRITING THIS work; a thing may be capable of BEING DONE, AND YET MAY NEVER BE DONE.
After reading the short treatises which I lately drew up for you, my beloved son Marcel- j linus, about the baptism of infants, and the per- fection of man's righteousness, — how that no one in this life seems either to have attained or to be likely to attain to it, except only the Me- diator, who bore humanity in the likeness of sinful flesh, without any sin whatever, — you 1 wrote me in answer that you were embarrassed by the point which I advanced in the second book,' that it was possible for a man to be without sin, if he wanted not the will, and was • On the Merits of Sins, etc., ii. 6, 7, 20.
assisted by the aid of God; and yet that except One in whom " all shall be made alive," ^ no one has ever lived or will live by whom this perfec- tion has been attained whilst living here. It appeared to you absurd to say that anything was possible of which no example ever occurred, — although I suppose you would not hesitate to admit that no camel ever passed through a needle's eye,^ and yet He said that even this was possible with God; you may read, too, that twelve thousand legions "* of angels could possi- bly have fought for Christ and rescued Him from suffering, but in fact did not; you may read that it was possible for the nations to be exterminated at once out of the land which was given to the ^ I Cor. XV. 22.
* Matlt. xxvi. 53, but observe the " thousand " inserted.
83 84 THE WORKS OF ST. AUGUSTIN.
[Chap. 2.
children of Israel,' and yet that God willed it to be gradually effected.- And one may meet with a thousand other incidents, the past or the future possibility of which we might readily admit, and yet be unable to produce any proofs of their ha\- ing ever really happened. Accordingly, it would not be right for us to deny the possibility of a man's living without sin, on the ground that amongst men none can be found except Him who is in His nature not man only, but also God, in whom we could prove such perfection of char- acter to have existed.
CH.\P. 2 [II.]
Here, perhaps, you will say to me in answer, that the things which I have instanced as not having been realized, although capable of reali- zation, are divine works; whereas a man's being without sin falls in the range of a man's own work, — that being indeed his very noblest work which effects a full and perfect righteousness complete in every part; and therefore that it is incredible that no man has ever existed, or is existing, or will exist in this life, who has achieved such a work, if the achievement is possible for a human being. But then you ought to reflect that, although this great work, no doubt, belongs to human agency to accomplish, yet it is also a divine gift, and therefore, not doubt that it is a divine work; " for it is God who worketh in you both to will and to do of His good pleasure." 3 CHAP. 3. THEIRS IS COMPARATIVELY A HARM- LESS ERROR, WHO SAY THAT A MAN LIVES HERE WITHOUT SIN.
They therefore are not a very dangerous set of persons and they ought to be urged to show, if they are able, that they are themselves such, who hold that man lives or has lived here without any sin whatever. There are indeed passages of Scripture, in which I apprehend it is definitely stated that no man who lives on earth, although enjoying freedom of will, can be found without sin; as, for instance, the place where it is writ- ten, " Enter not into judgment with Thy servant, for in Thy sight shall no man living be justified." •♦ If, however, anybody shall have succeeded in showing that this text and the other similar ones ought to be taken in a different sense from their obvious one, and shall have proved that some man or men have spent a sinless life on earth, — whoever does not, not merely refrain from much opposing him, but also does not rejoice with him to the full, is afflicted by extraordinary goads of envy. Moreover, if there neither is, has been, nor will be any man endowed with such perfec- tion of purity (which I am more inclined to be- ' Deut. xxxi. 3. ^ Judg. ii. 3. 3 Phil. ii. 13. ^ Ps. cxliii. 2.
lieve), and yet it is firmly set forth and thought there is or has been, or is to be, — so far as I can judge, no great error is made, and certainly not a dangerous one, when a man is thus carried away by a certain benevolent feeling; provided that he who thinks so much of another, does not think himself to be such a being, unless he has ascertained that he really and clearly is such.
CHAP. 4. THEIRS IS A MUCH MORE SERIOUS ERROR, REQUIRING A VERY VIGOROUS REFUTA- TION, WHO DENY god's GRACE TO BE NECES- SARY.
They, however, must be resisted with the ut- most ardor and vigor who suppose that without God's help, the mere power of the human will in itself, can either perfect righteousness, or ad- vance steadily towards it; and when they begin to be hard pressed about their presumption in asserting that this result can be reached without the divine assistance, they check themsehes, and do not venture to utter such an opinion,*because they see how impious and insufferable it is. But they allege that such attainments are not made without God's help on this account, namely, because God both created man with the free choice of his will, and, by giving him command- ments, teaches him. Himself, how man ought to live; and indeed assists him, in that He takes away his ignorance by instructing him in the knowledge of what he ought to avoid and to desire in his actions: and thus, by means of the free-will naturally implanted within him, he enters on the way which is pointed out to him, and by persevering in a just and pious course of life, de- serves to attain to the blessedness of eternal life.
CHAP. 5 [ill.] — TRUE GRACE IS THE GIFT OF THE HOLY GHOST, WHICH KINDLES IN THE SOUL THE JOY AND LOVE OF GOODNESS.
We, however, on our side affirm that the human will is so divinely aided in the pursuit of righteousness, that (in addition to man's be- ing created with a free-will, and in addition to the teaching by which he is instructed how he ought to live) he receives the Holy Ghost, by whom there is formed in his mind a delight in, and a love of, that supreme and unchangeable good which is God, even now while he is still " walking by faith " and not yet " by sight; " 5 in order that by this gift to him of the earnest, as it were, of the free gift, he may conceive an ardent desire to cleave to his Maker, and may burn to enter upon the participation in that true light, that it may go well with him from Him to whom he owes his existence. A man's free-will, indeed, avails for nothing except to sin, if he S 2 Cor. V. 7.
Chap. 7.]
ON THE SPIRIT AND THE LETTER.
85 knows not the way of truth; and even after his duty and his proper aim shall begin to become known to him, unless he also take delight in and feel a love for it, he neither does his duty, nor sets about it, nor lives rightly. Now, in order that such a course may engage our affections, God's " love is shed abroad in our hearts," not through the free-will which arises from ourselves, but " through the Holy Ghost, which is given to us." ' CHAP. 6 [iV.] — THE TEACHING OF LAW WITHOUT THE LIFE-GIVING SPIRIT IS " THE LETTER THAT KILLETH."
For that teaching which brings to us the com- mand to live in chastity and righteousness is " the letter that killeth," unless accompanied with " the spirit that giveth hfe." For that is not the sole meaning of the passage, " The letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life,- which merely prescribes that we should not take in the literal sense any figurative phrase which in the proper meaning of its words would produce only non- sense, but should consider what else it signi- fies, nourishing the inner man by our spiritual intelligence, since " being carnally-minded is death, whilst to be spiritually-minded is life and peace." ^ If, for instance, a man were to take in a literal and carnal sense much that is written in the Song of Solomon, he would minister not to the fruit of a luminous charity, but to the feeling of a libidinous desire. Therefore, the apostle is not to be confined to the hmited ap- plication just mentioned, when he says, " The letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life; " ^ but this is also (and indeed especially) equivalent to what he says elsewhere in the plainest words: " I had not known lust, except the law had said, Thou shalt not covet; " ■* and again, immediately after: " Sin, taking occasion by the commandment, deceived me, and by it slew me." s Now from this you may see what is meant by " the letter that killeth." There is, of course, nothing said figuratively which is not to be accepted in its plain sense, when it is said, " Thou shalt not covet; " but this is a very plain and salutary precept, and any man who shall fulfil it will have no sin at all. The aposde, indeed, purposely selected this general precept, in which he em- braced everything, as if this were the voice of the law, prohibiting us from all sin, when he says, "Thou shalt not covet;" for there is no sin committed except by evil concupiscence; so that the law which prohibits this is a good and praise- worthy law. But, when the Holy Ghost with- holds His help, which inspires us with a good desire instead of this evil desire (in other words, diffuses love in our hearts), that law, however good in itself, only augments the evil desire by forbidding it. Just as the rush of water which flows incessantly in a particular direction, be- comes more violent when it meets with any impediment, and when it has overcome the stoppage, falls in a greater bulk, and with in- creased impetuosity hurries forward in its down- ward course. In some strange way the very object which we covet becomes all the more pleasant when it is forbidden. And this is the sin which by the commandment deceives and by it slays, whenever transgression is actually added, which occurs not where there is no law.^ I CH.\P. 7 [v.] — WHAT IS PROPOSED TO BE HERE I TREATED.
We will, however, consider, if you please, the whole of this passage of the apostle and thorough- ly handle it, as the Lord shall enable us. For I want, if possible, to prove that the apostle's words, "The letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life," do not refer to figuradve phrases, — although even in this sense a suitable significa- tion might be obtained from them, — but rather plainly to the law, which forbids whatever is evil. When I shall have proved this, it will more manifestly appear that to lead a holy life is the gift of God, — not only because God has given a free-will to man, without which there is no living ill or well; nor only because He has given him a commandment to teach him how he ought to live; but because through the Holy Ghost He sheds love abroad in the hearts ■♦ of those whom he foreknew, in order to predestinate them; whom He predestinated, that He might call them; whom He called, that he might justify them; and whom he justified, that He might glorify them.'' When this point also shall be cleared, you will, I think, see how vain it is to say that those things only are unexampled possibilities, which are the works of God, — such as the pas- sage of the camel through the needle's eye, which we have already referred to, and other similar cases, which to us no doubt are impossi- ble, but easy enough to God; and that man's righteousness is not to be counted in this class of things, on the ground of its being properly man's work, not God's; although there is no reason for supposing, without an example, that his per- fection exists, even if it is possible. That these assertions are vain will be clear enough, after it has been also plainly shown that even man's righteousness must be attributed to the opera- tion of God, although not taking place without man's will; and we Xherefore cannot deny that his perfection is possible even in this life, because 6 Rom. iv. 15.
86 THE WORKS OF ST. AUGUSTIN.
[Chap.
all things are possible with God,' — both those which He accomplishes of His own sole will, and those which He appoints to be done with the co-operation with Himself of His creature's will. Accordingly, whatever of such things He does not effect is no doubt without an example in the way of accomplished facts, although with God it possesses both in His power the cause of its possibility, and in His wisdom the reason of its unreality. And should this cause be hidden from man, let him not forget that he is a man; nor charge God with folly simply because he cannot fully comprehend His wisdom.
CHAP. 8. — ROMANS INTERPRETS CORINTHIANS.
Attend, then, carefully, to the apostle while in his Epistle to the Romans he explains and clearly enough shows that what he wrote to the Corinthians, "The letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life," ^ must be understood in the sense which we have already indicated, — that the letter of the law, which teaches us not to com- mit sin, kills, if the life-giving spirit be absent, forasmuch as it causes sin to be known rather than avoided, and therefore to be increased rather than diminished, because to an evil con- cupiscense there is now added the transgression of the law.
CHAP. 9 [VI.] THROUGH THE LAW SIN HAS ABOUNDED.
The apostle, then, wishing to commend the grace which has come to all nations through Jesus Christ, lest the Jews should extol them- selves at the expense of the other peoples on account of their having received the law, first says that sin and death came on the human race through one man, and that righteousness and eternal life came also through one, expressly mentioning Adam as the former, and Christ as the latter; and then says that " the law, however, entered, that the offence might abound: but where sin abounded, grace did much more abound: that as sin hath reigned unto death, even so might grace reign through righteousness unto eternal life by Jesus Christ our Lord." ^ Then, proposing a question for himself to an- swer, he adds, " What shall we say then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound? God forbid." ■* He saw, indeed, that a perverse use might be made by perverse men of what he had said: " The law entered, that the offence might abound: but where sin abounded, grace did much more abound," — as if he had said that sin had been of advantage by reason of the abundance of grace. Rejecting this, he answers his question with a " God forbid! " and at once 3 Rom. V. 20, 21.
4 Rom. vi. I, 2.
adds: " How shall we, that are dead to sin, live any longer therein? " 5 as much as to say. When grace has brought it to pass that we should die unto sin, what else shall we be doing, if we con- tinue to live in it, than showing ourselves un- grateful to grace? The man who extols the virtue of a medicine does not contend that the diseases and wounds of which the medicine cures him are of advantage to him; on the con- trary, in proportion to the praise lavished on the remedy are the blame and horror which are felt of the diseases and wounds healed by the much- extolled medicine. In like manner, the com- mendation and praise of grace are vituperation and condemnation of offences. For there was need to prove to man how corruptly weak he was, so that against his iniquity, the holy law brought him no help towards good, but rather increased than diminished his iniquity; seeing that the law entered, that the offence might abound; that being thus convicted and confound- ed, he might see not only that he needed a physician, but also God as his helper so to direct his steps that sin should not rule over him, and he might be healed by betaking him- self to the help of the divine mercy; and in this way, where sin abounded grace might much more abound, — not through the merit of the sinner, but by the intervention of his Helper.
CHAP. lO. CHRIST THE TRUE HEALER.
Accordingly, the apostle shows that the same medicine was mystically set forth in the passion and resurrection of Christ, when he says, " Know ye not, that so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ w^ere baptized into His death? Therefore we were buried with Him by baptism into death; that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life. For if we have been planted together in the like- ness of His death, we shall be also in the likeness of His resurrection: knowing this, that our old man is crucified with Him, that the body of sin might be destroyed, that henceforth we should not serve sin. For he that is dead is just- ified from sin. Now, if we be dead with Christ, we believe that we shall also live with Him: knowing that Christ, being raised from the dead, dieth no more; death hath no more dominion over Him. For in that He died. He died unto sin once; but in that He liveth. He liveth unto God. Likewise reckon ye also yourselves to be dead indeed unto sin, but alive unto God through Jesus Christ our Lord." ^ Now it is plain enough that here by the mystery of the Lord's death and resurrection is figured the death of our old sinful life, and the rising of the new; and that here is 5 Rom. vi. 2.
6 Rom. vi. 3-11.
Chap. 13.]
ON THE SPIRIT AND THE LETTER.
87 shown forth the aboHtion of inicjuity and the renewal of righteousness. Whence then arises this vast benefit to man through the letter of the law, except it be through the faith of Jesus Christ?
CHAP. I I [VII.] — FROM WHAT FOUNTAIN GOOD WORKS FLOW.
This holy meditation preserves " the children of men, who put their trust under the shadow of God's wings," ' so that they are " drunken with the fatness of His house, and drink of the full stream of His pleasure. For with Him is the fountain of life, and in His light shall they see light. For He extendeth His mercy to them that know Him, and His righteousness to the upright in heart." ^ He does not, indeed, extend His mercy to them because they know Him, but that they may know Him; nor is it because they are upright in heart, but that they may become so, that He extends to them His righteousness, whereby He justifies the ungodly.^ This med- itation does not elevate with pride: this sin arises when any man has too much confidence in him- self, and makes himself the chief end of living. Impelled by this vain feeling, he departs from that fountain of life, from the draughts of which alone is imbibed the hohness which is itself the good life, — and from that unchanging light, by sharing in which the reasonable soul is in a cer- tain sense inflamed, and becomes itself a created and reflected luminary; even as " John was a burning and a shining light," ** who notwith- standing acknowledged the source of his own illumination in the words, " Of His fulness have all we received." s Whose, I would ask, but His, of course, in comparison wath whom John indeed was no light at all? For " that was the true light, which lighteth every man that cometh into the world." ^ Therefore, in the same psalm, after saying, " Extend Thy mercy to them that know Thee, and Thy righteousness to the upright in heart," ^ he adds, " Let not the foot of pride come against me, and let not the hands of sinners move me. There have fallen all the workers of iniquity: they are cast out, and are not able to stand." ^ Since by that impiety which leads each to attribute to himself the exceflence which is God's, he is cast out into his own native darkness, in which consist the works of iniquity. For it is manifestly these works which he does, and for the achievement of such alone is he naturally fit. The works of righteousness he never does, except as he receives abilitv from that fountain and that light, where the life is that wants for nothing.
' Ps. xxxvi. 7. ^ Ps. xxxvi. 8-10. 3 Rom. iv. 5.
^ Ps. xxxvi. 10.
and where is " no variableness, nor the shadow of turning." 9 CHAP. 12. — PAUL, WHENCE SO CALLED; BRAVELY CONTENDS FOR GRACE.