The kind of anniversary sermons to which a great part of what I write refers, if men are riot shamed out of their present course, in commemorating the fact, will cheat many out of the principles, and de- prive them of the benefits, of the Revolution they commemorate. I confess to you, Sir, I never liked this continual talk of resistance and revolution, or the practice of making the extreme medicine of the constitution its daily bread. It renders the habit of society dangerously valetudinary: it is taking pe- fiodical doses of mercury sublimate, and swallowing 84 B HONS ON rill down repeated provocatives of cantharides to our love of liberty. This distemper of remedy, grown habitual, relaxes and wears out, by a vulvar and prostituted use. the spring of that spirit which is to be exerted on great occasions. It was in the most patient period of Roman servitude that themes of tyrannicide made the ordi- nary exercise of boys at school— cum perir/iit aaoos classis numerosa tyrannos. In the ordinary state of things, it produces in a country like ours the worst effects, even on the cause of that liberty which it abuses with the dissoluteness of an extravagant speculation. Almost all the high-bred republicans of my time have, after a short space, become the most decided thorough-paced courtiers; they soon left the business of a tedious, moderate, but practical resis- tance, to those of us whom, in the pride and intoxi- cation of their theories, they have slighted as not much better than Tories. Hypocrisy, of course, de- lights in the most sublime speculations; for, never intending to go beyond speculation, it costs nothing to have it magnificent. But even in cases where rather levity than fraud was to be suspected in these ranting speculations, the issue has been much the same. These professors, finding their extreme prin- ciples not applicable to cases which call only for a qualified, or, as I may say, civil and legal resistance, in such eases employ no resistance at all. It is with them a war or a revolution, or it is nothing. Finding their schemes of politics not adapted to the state of the world in which they live, they often come to think lightly of all public principle: and are ready, on their part, to abandon for a very trivial interest what they REVOLUTION IN FRANCE. 85 find of very trivial value. Some indeed are of more steady and persevering natures; but these are eager politicians out of parliament, who have little to tempt them to abandon their favourite projects. They have some change in the church or state, or both, con- stantly in their view. When that is the case, they are always bad citizens, and perfectly unsure con- nexions. For, considering their speculative designs as of infinite value, and the actual arrangement of the state as of no estimation, they are at best indifferent about it. They see no merit in the good, and no fault in the vicious management of public affairs; they rather rejoice in the latter, as more propitious to revo- lution. They see no merit or demerit in any man, or any action, or any political principle, any further than as they may forward or retard their design of change: they therefore take up, one day, the most violent and stretched prerogative, and another time the wildest democratic ideas of freedom, and pass from the one to the other without any sort of regard to cause, to person, or to party.
In France you are now in the crisis of a revolution, and in the transit from one form of government to another — you cannot see that character of men exactly in the same situation in which we see it in this coun- try. With us it is militant — with you it is trium- phant; and you know how it can act when its power is commensurate to its will. I would not be supposed to confine those observations to any description of men, or to comprehend all men of any description within them — No! far from it. I am as incapable of that injustice, as I am of keeping terms with those who profess principles of extremes; and who, under the i 86 REFLECT], hi: i 86 REFLECT], hi: name of religion, teach little else than wild and dan- gerous politics. The worst of these politics of revo- lution is this: they temper and harden the breast, in order to prepare it for the desperate strokes which are sometimes used on extreme occasions. But as I occasions may never arrive, the mind receives a gra- tuitous taint; and tin moral sentiments suffer not a little, when no political purpose is served by the depravation. This sort of people are so taken up with their theories about the rights of man, that they have totally forgotten bis nature. Without opening one new avenue to the understanding, they have suc- ceeded in stopping up those that lead to the heart. They have perverted in themselves, and in those that attend to them, all the well-placed sympathies of the human breast.
This famous sermon of the Old Jewry breathe-; nothing but this spirit through all the political part. Plots, massacres. tions, seem to some people a trivial price for obtaining a revolution. A cheap, bloodies* reformation, a guiltless liberty, appear flat and vapid to their taste. There must be a great change of scene; there must be a magnificent effect; there must be a grand spectacle to rouse the imagination, grown torpid with the lazy enjoyment of sixty years' security, and the still unanimatiug re- pose of public prosperity. The preacher found them all in the French Revolution. This inspires a juvenile warmth through his whole frame. His enthusiasm kindles as he advances; and when he arrives at his peroration, it is in a full blaze. Then viewing, from the Pisgah of bis pulpit, the free, moral, happy, flourishing, and glori< •; France, as in a bird- BETOLUTION IN FRANCE. 87 eye landscape of a promised land, he breaks out into the following rapture: " What an eventful period is this! I am thankful that I have lived to it; I could almost say, Lord, now lettest thou thy servant depart in peace, for mine eyes have seen thy salvation. I have lived to see a dif- fusion of knowledge, which has undermined super- stition and error.— I have lived to see the rights of men better understood than ever; and nations panting for liberty which seemed to have lost the idea of it I have lived to see thirty millions of people, indig- nant and resolute, spurning at slavery, and demanding liberty with an irresistible voice. Their king led in triumph, and an arbitrary monarch surrendering himself to his subjects."* Before I proceed further, I have to remark, that Dr. Price seems rather to overvalue the great ac- quisitions of light which he has obtained and diffused in this age. The last century appears to me to haye been quite as much enlightened. It had, though in a different place, a triumph as memorable as that of Dr. Price; and some of the great preachers of that period partook of it as eagerly as he has done in the triumph of France. On the trial of the Rev. Hugh Peters for high treason, it was deposed, that when King Charles was brought to London for his trial, the Apostle of Liberty in that day conducted the triumph. " I saw," says the witness, "his majesty in the coach * Another of these reverend gentlemen, who was witness to some of the spectacles which Paris has lately exhihited, expresses himself thus: — "A king dragged in submissive triumph by his conquering sub- jects, is one of those appearances of grandeur which seldom rise in the prospect of human affairs, and which, during the remainder of my life, I shall think of with wonder and gratification." These gentlemen agree marvellously in their feelings.
88 REFLECTIONS ON Till with six horses, and Peters riding before the king, triumphing." Dr. Price, when lie talks as if he had made a discovery, only follows a precedent; for, after the commmencement of the king's trial, this pre- cursor, the same Dr. Peters, concluding a long prayer at the royal chapel at Whitehall, (he had very tri- umphantly chosen his place, said, " I have prayed and preached these twenty years; and now 1 may say with old Simeon, Lord, now lettest thou thy servant tit-part in peace, for nunc eyes hare seen tlnj sal- ration."* Peters had^ not the fruits of his prayer: for he neither departed so soon as he wished, nor in peace. He became (what I heartily hope none of his followers may be in this country) himself a sacrifice to the triumph which he led as pontiff. They dealt al the Restoration, perhaps, too hardly with this poor good man. Put we owe it to his memory and his sufferings, that he had as much illumination, and as much zeal, and had as effectually undermined all tin superstition and error which might impede the great business lie was engaged in, as any who follow and repeat after him, in this age, which would assume to itself an exclusive title to the knowledge of the rights of men, and all the glorious consequences of that knowledge.
After this sally of the preacher of the Old Jewry, which differs only in place and time, hut agrees per- fectly with the spirit and letter of the rapture of 1648, the Revolution Society, the fabricators of govern- ments, the heroic band of cashierers of monarchs, electors of sovereigns, and leaders of kings in triumph. strutting with a proud consciousness of the diffusion Trials, vol.. p REVOLUTION IN it.iMi 89 of knowledge, of which every member had obtained so large a share in the donative, were in haste to make a generous diffusion of the knowledge they had thus gratuitously received. To make this bountiful communication, they adjourned from the church in the Old Jewry, to the London Tavern; where the same Dr. Price, in whom the fumes of his oracular tripod were not entirely evaporated, moved and carried the resolution, or address of congratulation, transmitted by Lord Stanhope to the National Assembly of France.
I find a preacher of the gospel profaning the beautiful and prophetic ejaculation, commonly called "Nunc dimittis," made on the first presentation of our Saviour in the temple, and applying it, with an inhuman and unnatural rapture, to the most horrid, atrocious, and afflicting spectacle, that perhaps ever was exhibited to the pity and indignation of mankind. This "leading in triumph," a thing in its best form unmanly and irreligious, which fills our preacher with such unhallowed transports, must shock, I believe, the moral taste of every well-born mind. Several English were the stupified and indig- nant spectators of that triumph. It was (unless we have been strangely deceived) a spectacle more resembling a procession of American savages, enter- ing into Onondago, after some of their murders called victories, and leading into hovels hung round with scalps, their captives, overpowered with the scoffs and buffets of women as ferocious as them- selves, much more than it resembled the triumphal pomp of a civilized, martial nation; — if;i civilized nation, or any men who had a sense of generosity, i3 90 UKFLli TIONS ON TUB were capable of a personal triumph over the fallen and afflicted.
Tins, my dear Sir, was not the triumph of France. I must believe that, as a nation, it overwhelmed you with shame and horror. 1 must believe that the National Assembly find themselves in a state of the greatest humiliation, in not being able to punish the authors of this triumph, or the actors in it; and that they are in a situation in which any inquiry they may make upon the subject must be destitute even of the appearance of liberty or impartiality. The apology of that Assembly is found in their situation; but when we approve what they must bear, it is in us the degenerate choice of a vitiated mind.
With a compelled appearance of deliberation, they vote under the dominion of a stern necessity. They sit in the heart, as it were, of a foreign republic: they have their residence in a city whose constitution has emanated neither from the charter of their king, nor from their legislative power. There they are sur- rounded by an army not raised either by the authority of their crown, or by their command; and which, if they should order to dissolve itself, would instantly dissolve them. There they sit, after a gang of as- sassins had driven away all the men of moderate minds and moderating authority amongst them, and left them as a sort of dregs and refuse, under the ap- parent lead of those in whom they do not so much as pretend to have any confidence. There they sit, in mockery of legislation, repeating in resolutions the words of those whom they detest and despise. Cap- tives themselves, they compel a captive king to issue as royal edicts, at third hand, the polluted nonsense REVOLUTION IN FRANCE. 91 of their most licentious and giddy coffee-houses. It is notorious, that all their measures are decided be- fore they are debated. It is beyond doubt, that, under the terror of the bayonet and the lamp-post and the torch to their houses, they are obliged to adopt all the crude and desperate measures suggested by clubs composed of a monstrous medley of all con- ditions, tongues, and nations. Among these are found persons, in comparison of whom Catiline would be thought scrupulous, and Cethegus a man of sobriety and moderation. Nor is it in these clubs alone that the public measures are deformed into monsters. They undergo a previous distortion in academies, in- tended as so many seminaries for these clubs, which are set up in all the places of public resort. In these meetings of all sorts, every counsel, in proportion as it is daring, and violent, and perfidious, is taken for the mark of superior genius. Humanity and com- passion are ridiculed as the fruits of superstition and ignorance. Tenderness to individuals is considered as treason to the public. Liberty is always to be estimated perfect as property is rendered insecure. Amidst assassination, massacre, and confiscation, per- petrated or meditated, they are forming plans for the good order of future society. Embracing in their arms the carcases of base criminals, and promoting their relations on the title of their offences, they drive hundreds of virtuous persons to the same end, by forcing them to subsist by beggary or by crime.
The Assembly, their organ, acts before them the farce of deliberation with as little decency as liberty. They act like the comedians of a fair before a riotous audience; they art amidst the tumultuous cries of a mixed mob of ferocious men, and of women lost to shame, who, according to their insolent fancies, direct, control, applaud, explode them; and sometimes mix and take their seats amongst them; domineering over them with a strange mixture of servile petulance and proud, presumptuous authority. As they have in- verted order in all things, the gallery is in the place of the house. This Assembly, which overthrows kings and kingdoms, has not even the physiognomy and aspect of a grave legislative body — nee color im- perii, nee from erat uHu senatus. They have a power given to them, like that of the evil principle, to sub- vert and destroy; but none to construct, except such machines as may be fitted for further subversion and further destruction.
Who is it that admires, and from the heart is at- tached to, national representative assemblies, but must turn with horror and disgust from such a profane burlesque, and abominable perversion of that sacred institute? Lovers of monarchy, lovers of republics, must alike abhor it. The members of your Assembly must themselves groan under the tyranny of which they have all the shame, none of the direction, and little of the profit. I am sure many of the members who compose even the majority of that body, must feel as I do, notwithstanding the applauses of the Revolution Society. — Miserable king! miserable Assembly! How must that assembly be silently scandalized with those of their members, who could call a day which seemed to blot the sun out of heaven. " //// beau jourt"-* How must they be inwardly indignant at hearing Others, who thought tit to declare to them, "that the « 6th of October, ' REVOLUTION IN FRANCE. 93 vessel of the state would fly forward in her course towards regeneration with more speed than ever," from the stiff gale of treason and murder, which pre- ceded our preacher's triumph! What must they have felt, whilst, with outward patience and inward in- dignation, they heard of the slaughter of innocent gentlemen in their houses, that "the blood spilled was not the most pure? " What must they have felt, when they were besieged by complaints of disorders which shook their country to its foundations, at being compelled coolly to tell the complainants, that they were under the protection of the law, and that they would address the king (the captive king) to cause the laws to be enforced for their protection; when the enslaved ministers of that captive king had for- mally notified to them, that there were neither law, nor authority, nor power left to protect? What must they have felt at being obliged, as a felicitation on the present new year, to request their captive king to forget the stormy period of the last, on account of the great good which he was likely to produce to his people; to the complete attainment of which good they adjourned the practical demonstrations of their loyalty, assuring him of their obedience, when he should no longer possess any authority to command?
This address was made with much good-nature and affection, to be sure. But among the revolutions in France must be reckoned a considerable revo- lution in their ideas of politeness. In England we are said to learn manners at second-hand from your side of the water, and that we dress our behaviour in the frippery of France. If so, we are still in the old iiit: and have not so far conformed to the new 94 REFLECTIONS OX THE Parisian mode of good-breeding, as to think it quite in the most refined strain of delicate compliment (whether in condolence or congratulation) to say, to the most humiliated creature that crawls upon the earth, that great public benefits are derived from the murder of his servants, the attempted assassination of himself and of his wife, and the mortification, disgrace, and degradation, that he has personally suffered. It is a topic of consolation which our ordinary of Newgate would be too humane to use to a criminal at the foot of the gallows. I should have thought that the hangman of Paris, now that he is liberalized by the vote of the National Assembly, and is allowed his rank and arms in the herald's college of the rights of men, would be too generous, too gallant a man, too full of the sense of his new dignity, to employ that cutting consola- tion to any of the persons whom the kze nation might bring under the administration of his executive powt r.
A man is fallen indeed, when he is thus flattered. The anodyne draught of oblivion, thus drugged, is well calculated to preserve a galling wakefulness, and to feed the living ulcer of a corroding memory. Thus to administer the opiate potion of amnesty, powdered with all the ingredients of scorn and con- tempt, is to hold to his lips, instead of "the balm of hurt minds," the cup of human misery full to the brim, and to force him to drink it to the dregs.
Yielding to reasons, at least as forcible as those which were so delicately urged in the compliment on the new year, the king of France will probably endeavour to forget these events and that compli- REVOLUTION IN FRANCE. 95 ment. But history, who keeps a durable record of all our acts, and exercises her awful censure over the proceedings of all sorts of sovereigns, will not forget either those events, or the era of this liberal refinement in the intercourse of mankind. History will record, that on the morning of the 6th of October, 1789, the king and queen of France, after a day of confusion, alarm, dismay, and slaughter, lay down, under the pledged security of public faith, to indulge nature in a few hours of respite, and troubled melancholy repose. From this sleep the queen was first startled by the voice of the centinel at her door, who cried out to her to save herself by flight — that this was the last proof of fidelity he could give — that they were upon him, and he was dead. Instantly he was cut down. A band of cruel ruffians and assassins, reeking with his blood, rushed into the chamber of the queen, and pierced with a hundred strokes of bayonets and poniards the bed, from whence this persecuted woman had but just time to fly almost naked, and, through ways unknown to the murderers had escaped to seek refuge at the feet of a king and husband, not secure of his own life for a moment.
This king, to say no more of him, and this queen, and their infant children (who once would have been the pride and hope of a great and generous people), were then forced to abandon the sanctuary of the most splendid palace in the world, which they left swimming in blood, polluted by massacre, and strewed with scattered limbs and mutilated carcases. Thence they were conducted into the capital of their kingdom. Two had been selected from the unpro- )f! REFLECTIONS ON nil voked, unresisted, promiscuous slaughter, which was made of the gentlemen of birth and family who • composed the king's body guard. These two gentlemen, with all the parade of an execution of justice, were cruelly and publicly dragged to the block, and beheaded in the great court of the palace. Their heads were stuck upon spears, and led the procession; whilst the royal captives who followed in the train were slowly moved along, amidst the horrid yells, and shrilling screams, and frantic dances, and infamous contumelies, and all the unutterable abominations of the furies of hell, in the abused shape of the vilest of women. After they had been made to taste, drop by drop, more than the bitterness of death, in the slow torture of a journey of twelve miles, protracted to six hours, they were, under a guard composed of those very soldiers who had thus conducted them through this famous triumph, lodged in one of the old palaces of Paris, now con- verted into a Bastile for kings.
Is this a triumph to be consecrated at altars? to be commemorated with grateful thanksgiving? to be offered to the divine humanity with fervent prayei and enthusiastic ejaculation V — These Thehan and Thracian orgies, acted in France, and applauded only in the Old Jewry. 1 assure you. kindle pro- phetic enthusiasm in the minds hut of very few- people in this kingdom; although a saint and apostle, who may have revelations of his own, and who has so completely vanquished all the mean superstitions of the heart, may incline to think it pious and decorous to compare it with the entrance into the world of the Prince of Peace, proclaimed REVOLUTION IN FRANCE. 97 in a holy temple by a venerable sage, and not long before not worse announced by the voice of angels to the quiet innocence of shepherds.
At first I was at a loss to account for this fit of unguarded transport. I knew, indeed, that the sufferings of monarchs make a delicious repast to some sort of palates. There were reflections which might serve to keep this appetite within some bounds of temperance. But when I took one circumstance into my consideration, I was obliged to confess, that much allowance ought to be made for the Society, and that the temptation was too strong for common discretion; I mean, the circumstance of the Io Paean of the triumph, the animating cry which called for " nil the bishops to be hanged on the lamp-posts,"* might well have brought forth a burst of enthusiasm on the foreseen consequences of this happy day. I allow to so much enthusiasm some little deviation from prudence. I allow this prophet to break forth into hymns of joy and thanksgiving on an event which appears like the precursor of the Millennium, and the projected fifth monarchy, in the destruction of all church establishments. There was, however, (as in all human affairs there is,) in the midst of this joy something to exercise the patience of these worthy gentlemen, and to try the long-suffering of their faith. The actual murder of the king and queen, and their child, was wanting to the other auspicious circumstances of this "beautiful dap." The actual murder of the bishops, though called for by so many holy ejaculations, was also * Tons les Eveques a la lanterne.
wanting. A group of regicide and sacrili slaughter was indeed boldly sketched, but it was only sketched. It unhappily was left unfinished in this trreat history-piece of the massacre of innocents. What hardy pencil of a great master, from the school of the rights of men, will finish it, is to be seen hereafter. The age has not yet the complete benefit of that diffusion of knowledge that has undermined superstition and error; and the king of France wants another object or two, to consign to oblivion, in consideration of all the good which is to ari.se from his own sufferings, and the patriotic crimes of an enlightened age.* * It is proper here to refer to a letter written upon this subject by an eye-witness. That eye-witness was one of the most I intelligent, and eloquent members of the National Assembly, one i>: the most active and zealous reformers of the state, lie was to secede from the Assembly; and he afterwards became a voluntary exile, on account of the horrors of this pious triumph, and the dispositions of men who, profiting of crimes, if not causing them, have taken the lead in public affairs.
Extract of M. deLally Tollendal's Second Letter to a Friend.